unemployment insurance in reverse
Federico Imparatta · · originally published on LinkedIn →
this is a translation of the spanish original · read the original →
in 2020, unemployment insurance supported those who could not work from home. the next shock hits those who could, and for them the safety net is capped—or does not exist at all.
in may 2020, 185,769 people in uruguay were receiving unemployment benefits. three months earlier, the number had been less than half that. retail, manufacturing, hospitality, education. meanwhile, one in five employed people took their computer home and kept receiving their full salary.
those of us who stayed home on full pay were, on average, the higher earners with more years of education: finance, ict, professional services. unemployment insurance, the state's cushion against joblessness, covered the others.
what comes next is the picture reversed. the layoffs being announced at service hubs—basf, sabre, ukg—hit precisely the people who did not need that cushion in 2020. and that cushion was not designed for them.
the cushion of 2020
the statistical unit of the ministry of labor and social security, mtss, recorded 117,944 unemployment-benefit recipients in march 2020, 157% more than in february. the peak came in may, at 185,769. by september, it had fallen to 95,962.
the important figure is not the total but the reason. in june 2020, minister pablo mieres said only 8 or 9% of applications followed dismissals. the rest were temporary suspensions: people who would return to their jobs when activity resumed. the insurance worked as a bridge, not an exit.
on the other side, remote work rose from around 5% of employed people to almost 20% in april 2020. rafael guntín had estimated that only 22% of employed people could do it. gabriel burdín described who they were: relatively high-income, educated people in finance, ict, education, and professional services.
that 20% received their full salary. many saved more than ever, because there was nowhere to spend it. the crisis hit those who had to be physically present, and the state threw them a life buoy designed for that salary range.
the profile of the next wave
uruguay xxi estimates that global services employ more than 32,000 people. this is not just software: accounting, finance, human resources, legal services, data analysis. in 2021, there were more than 50 shared-service centers with around 11,670 jobs.
this is the population affected by the layoffs of the past two years. in march, i counted at least 1,300 between 2024 and 2026: ukg, sabre, basf, pedidosya, verizon/alorica. basf alone announced 360 to 480 fewer jobs through 2028 at its wtc hub, while opening a center in hyderabad.
three differences from 2020:
- these are dismissals, not temporary suspensions. there is no job to return to: it moved to another country or was absorbed by a tool.
- these are high salaries for the local market. the it sector averages around 91,157 uruguayan pesos gross per month, and a senior finance or analytics professional at a corporate hub earns more.
- these are people with tertiary education, many graduates of public institutions, and in several of these centers most are women.
someone who loses that job does not fall into poverty. they fall into a place for which there is no policy: the middle-class professional, with middle-class fixed costs, in a market that will not rehire them at the same level.
the ceiling
unemployment insurance following dismissal pays a declining percentage of the average of the last six salaries: 66% in the first month, then 57, 50, 45, 42, and 40%. each month also has a ceiling that declines: in 2026, it runs from 93,155 pesos in the first month to 50,802 in the sixth.
at the sector's average salary, the ceiling does not bite. for the senior professional at a corporate hub, it does.
unemployment insurance covers half until the salary exceeds roughly 127,000 pesos. above that, the cap sets the amount. outside the payroll, there is nothing.
above roughly 141,000 pesos gross, the insurance becomes a fixed sum: 406,487 pesos over six months, whatever you used to earn. someone who earned 200,000 receives the same as someone who earned 145,000, and by the sixth month it covers a quarter of the former's salary.
the design makes sense. public insurance does not have to sustain high living standards, and statutory severance—one month's salary per year worked, up to six—does not have that ceiling. the problem is not the cap. it is that nobody has worked out what happens when mass layoffs hit just above it.
and all of this applies only to those who have insurance.
those without insurance
a large part of the sector does not appear in any of these calculations. bps unemployment benefits cover private-sector workers who provide paid services to third parties. they explicitly exclude business owners in their capacity as owners.
in technology and professional services, many people are not on a payroll. they invoice as sole proprietors or through their own simplified joint-stock company, a sas, serving a foreign client or a local company that prefers not to employ them. when the client ends the contract, there is no dismissal. no unemployment insurance, no severance, no notice period. there is an email.
that group had no cushion in 2020 either. the state offered sole proprietors an interest-free loan of 12,000 pesos in may and 12,000 in june, repayable in 24 installments. the only grant, 6,779 pesos a month for two months, went to sole proprietors without employees registered under the mides social single-tax scheme. a loan is not insurance: it is debt.
the closest estimate comes from cuti itself. in its 2022 survey, covering almost 20,000 people working in the sector, employees accounted for 69%. the other 31%, around 6,000 people, work with companies in the sector without being employees: partners, contractors who invoice, sole-proprietor suppliers. none receives unemployment insurance if the work stops.
and that count only covers companies that answer the survey. it excludes people who invoice foreign clients directly and appear in no sector statistics. since 2023, law 20.130 has allowed them to contribute to bps as non-employees; bps does not publish how many do so.
the broader trend points the same way. between july 2025 and july 2026, employer contribution positions registered with bps in industry and commerce grew 4.4%; employee positions grew 1.7%. in 2011, there were 79,001 sole proprietorships without employees; by april 2020, 105,505. not all of this is tech, but an increasing share of formal work takes place outside an employment relationship.
for this profile, the problem is not the ceiling. it is the absence of a floor. and it is the most exposed profile: the contractor doing describable work that a team with agents now performs with fewer people, whose contract gets cut first because cutting it costs nothing.
the family as insurance
between the salary that disappears and what bps covers, when it covers anything, there is a gap someone pays. severance covers it for a while, for those who receive it. savings cover a little more. then comes the family, which in uruguay has always been the last line of support, whether public policy says so or not.
the problem is the direction of the flow. in 2020, those of us who kept receiving full pay were often the ones supporting others: a sibling on unemployment benefits, a parent whose shop had closed. that network worked because the blow landed below and the money was above.
now the blow lands above. and the people who would have to support the dismissed professional are retired parents, who live longer than their own parents and spend on care what used to become an inheritance, or siblings with their own children in private schools and their own loan payments. there is nowhere to draw from.
that household's fixed costs do not adjust to the benefit either. school fees, rent or mortgage, family healthcare contributions, the car: all were taken on against the previous salary. an income that falls to a third is not absorbed by cutting back on evenings out. it is absorbed by selling things, moving the children to another school, or looking for work abroad.
and when work appears, it is rarely at the same level. the job that moved to hyderabad does not come back, and the remaining local market does not pay those salaries.
the chain nobody looks at
debates about these layoffs stop at direct employment: how many jobs, which company, which country they move to. the second ring is missing.
that professional profile, earning 100,000 to 200,000 pesos, makes up a substantial part of uruguay's premium market. these are customers of the local clothing brand, the cosmetics entrepreneur, the pocitos restaurant, the private school, the gym, the new apartment sold off-plan. many of these businesses are small, many are run by women, and none appears in the cuti report.
a market of 3.5 million people has a small, concentrated premium segment. the entire professional middle class does not have to disappear for that segment to suffer. a few thousand households switching from spending to fear-driven saving, at the same time, in the same neighborhood, are enough.
we already know how fragile that market is: temu only had to start selling here for shopping-mall owners to complain. now the blow does not come from competition. it comes from demand.
what appears in no spreadsheet
in 2020, the state knew who was receiving unemployment benefits, in which sector and department. today, it does not know the profile of collective dismissals in global services: salary band, sex, age, or how many people find work six months later and at what salary.
three things could be done without reinventing anything:
- measure. the advance-notice bill the mtss presented in march requires notification before a collective dismissal. that notice could include the profile of those dismissed: salary band, sex, age, education. bps already holds all of that; what is missing is linking and publishing it. and we need to count what currently appears nowhere: canceled contracts with sole proprietors and sas companies, which nobody counts as dismissals.
- collect. a company that operated for years with irae corporate-income-tax exemptions and then lays people off en masse could fund an insurance supplement for those above the cap. it is not punishment. it is the partial repayment of an incentive granted in exchange for employment.
- reintegrate differently. reskilling programs are designed for people who did not finish secondary school or want to learn programming. not for an accountant with fifteen years of experience whose job moved to india.
in 2020, the life buoy arrived in time because the problem was familiar: people who could not go to work. today's problem is familiar too. what is missing is the calculation.
sources
- mtss, statistical unit, territorial assessment of the labor market, 2019–2020. unemployment-benefit recipients: 117,944 in march 2020, 185,769 in may, 95,962 in september. sole proprietorships without employees: 79,001 in 2011, 105,505 in april 2020.
- montevideo portal, pablo mieres: we are recovering, but very slowly, 2020. 8 or 9% of applications followed dismissals.
- bustamante and salsamendi, remote work and rights: a look at uruguay, fes, october 2021. remote work rose from roughly 5% to 20% of employed people; segmentation by education.
- la mañana, interview with gabriel burdín, 2021. guntín's estimate (22%) and the profile of those able to work remotely.
- bps, unemployment benefits following dismissal. eligibility, exclusion of business owners, the 66/57/50/45/42/40% scale, and monthly 2026 caps (93,155 to 50,802 pesos).
- bps, workers for foreign employers without a local establishment. non-employee contribution regime since august 2023, law 20.130.
- bps, general advisory office for social security, ii. collections, data through july 2026. employer and employee contribution positions in industry and commerce.
- cuti, 2022 cuti survey, main results. almost 20,000 people in work; employees represented 69% of the total.
- mef, support measures adopted during the pandemic, may 2020. 12,000 + 12,000 peso loans to sole proprietors, 24 installments.
- law 19.877, 2020. a monthly 6,779 peso grant to sole proprietors without employees under the mides social single-tax scheme.
- uruguay xxi, global export services. more than 32,000 jobs in 2022.
- el observador, the boom in shared services in uruguay, 2021. more than 50 centers, around 11,670 jobs.
- imparatta, the state trains, the multinational harvests and leaves, march 2026. layoffs in 2024–2026, basf, average it salary, advance-notice bill.